Flatiron is one of Manhattan’s most dynamic food neighborhoods, and yes, that includes pizza.
From blistered Neapolitan pies to paper-thin crusts and inventive chef creations, this area offers options for every type of pizza enthusiast.
I’ve lived in the neighborhood for years, and in 2025 alone, I re-tested over a dozen local pizza joints to narrow it down to the best of the best. The best five spots for pizza Flatiron has are open, active, and worthy of your cravings.
🔥 Best Pizza Flatiron: Top 5 Picks
🥇 1. Tappo Thin Crust Pizza
- 📍 32 E 21st St, New York, NY 10010
- 🗺️ Cross streets: Between Park Ave South & Broadway
- ✨ Vibe: Casual, local, always buzzing
- 🍕 Must-Try: Arugula & Prosciutto or White Truffle Pizzas
- 💬 Local Tip: Ask for your pizza extra crispy, it’s how regulars order it for a reason
- 🏆 Highlights: Longtime neighborhood staple, delivery available, ultra-thin crust
- 🍕 Menu: Tappo Menu
Why Go:
Tappo is the go-to spot for thin-crust pizza done right. Nothing fancy, just reliable flavor, fresh toppings, and a crispy base. It’s fast, affordable, and ideal for lunch, a casual dinner, or takeout.
🥈 2. Zero Otto Nove
- 📍 15 W 21st St, New York, NY 10010
- 🗺️ Cross streets: 5th Ave & W 21st St
- ✨ Vibe: Warm, rustic, Southern Italian trattoria
- 🍕 Must-Try: Margherita or La Riccardo (butternut squash, pancetta, smoked mozzarella)
- 💬 Local Tip: Book a reservation in advance, seats fill up fast
- 🏆 Highlights: Brick oven, Arthur Ave roots, OpenTable reservations available
- 🍕 Menu: Zero Otto Nove Menu
Why Go:
Zero Otto Nove brings Southern Italy to Flatiron. With its roaring oven and charred crusts, the pies here are bold and comforting. It’s a favorite for date nights, group dinners, and anyone who loves traditional Italian food.
🥉 3. Stretch Pizza
- 📍 331 Park Ave South, New York, NY 10010
- 🗺️ Cross streets: Park Ave South & E 25th St
- ✨ Vibe: Modern, creative, chef-led
- 🍕 Must-Try: Vodka pizza with sesame crust
- 💬 Local Tip: Sit at the pizza bar for a front-row seat to the action in the kitchen
- 🏆 Highlights: Chef Wylie Dufresne, playful toppings, counter seating
- 🍕 Menu: Stretch Pizza Menu
Why Go:
Stretch is what happens when a world-class chef decides to get weird with pizza — in the best way. Sesame crust, sourdough base, and sauces you’ll want to dip everything in. It’s flat-out fun and surprisingly affordable.
🏅 4. La Pizza & La Pasta at Eataly Flatiron
- 📍 200 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010
- 🗺️ Cross streets: 5th Ave & W 23rd St
- ✨ Vibe: Bustling, open kitchen, Italian market energy
- 🍕 Must-Try: Bufalina DOP or Tartufo
- 💬 Local Tip: Visit before 6 PM or after 8 PM to avoid peak time crowds
- 🏆 Highlights: Neapolitan-style pizza with DOP ingredients; inside Eataly Flatiron
- 🍕 Menu: La Pizza Menu
Why Go:
Inside Eataly, this pizzeria offers a slice of Naples with DOP-certified ingredients and wood-fired perfection. It’s a great choice for families, tourists, or anyone craving classic Italian craftsmanship.
🎖️ 5. Roma Pizza
- 📍 146 5th Ave, Manhattan, NY 10011
- 🗺️ Cross streets: Between 19th and 20th Street, facing 5th avenue
- ✨ Vibe: Truly local
- 🍕 Must-Try: Any of their specialty pies
- 💬 Local Tip: Pair your pizza with a delicious salad for balance
- 🏆 Highlights: A local haunt perfect for food on the go
- 🍕 Menu: Roma Pizza Menu
Why Go:
Roma Pizza is the kind of place where everyone feels like a New Yorker. Even if if feels like one of those hole-in-the-wall kind of places, their quality will surprise you.
📊 Quick Comparison of the Best Pizza Flatiron Has
| Pizza Spot | Style | Vibe | Best For | WiFi |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tappo | Ultra-thin NY | Casual | Quick bites, takeout | ✅ |
| Zero Otto Nove | Brick oven Italian | Cozy, rustic | Group dinners | ✅ |
| Stretch Pizza | Modern, creative | Sleek, playful | Foodies, unique pies | ✅ |
| Eataly – La Pizza | Neapolitan | Busy market | Families, tourists | ✅ |
| Roma Pizza | Local | New Yorker | Food on the go | ✅ |
🚫 Not for Everyone
- Tappo – Too thin for fans of deep-dish or doughy crusts
- Stretch – Inventive toppings might not be for pizza purists
- Zero Otto Nove – Rich and hearty; not light fare
- Eataly – Gets tourist-heavy and loud during peak hours
- Roma – Not a traditional sit-down kind of place
🗺️ Pizza Flatiron: Map
🚇 Closest Subways
- N/R/W at 23rd St
- 6 Train at 22nd & Park Ave
- F/M/1 at 23rd St (6th Ave)
🕐 Best Times to Go
- Tappo – Lunch or early dinner for quick service
- Zero Otto Nove – Reservations around 7–8 PM
- Stretch – Weekday lunches or 5 PM seatings
- Eataly – Before 6 PM or after 8 PM
- Roma Pizza – Lunch or later weekday dinners
💭Pizza Flatiron: FAQ
What’s the Best Pizza in Flatiron for Groups?
Zero Otto Nove. There is a full dining setup, rustic feel, and reservations are accepted.
Which Flatiron Pizza Spots Offer Takeout or Delivery?
Tappo offers both. Stretch and Eataly also do takeout.
What’s the Most Creative Pizza Option?
Stretch Pizza! It is known for bold flavors and sesame crusts.
Is It Necessary to Make a Reservation for Three People for Lunch at Tappo Thin Crust Pizza?
Not necessary but definitely recommended. Place gets packed at lunchtime. Otherwise try showing up right around noon.
What Time Is Happy Hour at Zero Otto Nove?
It is from 5:00pm to 7:00pm